Twists, cuts, and awkward landings can strain the knee during sports and everyday life. The anterior cruciate ligament, or more commonly referred to as the ACL, and meniscus tears are the two most discussed knee injuries. This guide explains what each injury is, how it happens, what symptoms to look for, and how recovery works. You will learn how a licensed physical therapist can help you reduce pain, restore strength, and return to what you love.
Reviewed and contributions made by VP of Clinical Development Thomas Denninger
Key Takeaways
- ACL injury recovery focuses on stability, strength, and control for cutting and landing, with or without surgery.
- Meniscus tear treatment often starts with rehab; surgery is reserved for persistent symptoms or specific tear types.
- Knee injury symptoms overlap, including both swelling and popping; however, catching or locking suggests a meniscus tear.
- Many decisions do not require an immediate MRI. A skilled exam guides the next steps.
- If knee pain began with a sports injury or a twist, a physical therapist can evaluate and start a plan right away.
Why These Knee Injuries Cause Confusion
Knee injuries often share similar signs. Swelling, popping, and pain with turning can show up with both ACL and meniscus tears. Add in shaky internet advice, and it is hard to know what you are dealing with. This article breaks down the basics in plain language, so you can tell the difference between ACL injury symptoms and meniscus tear symptoms, know what treatment options look like, and understand ACL versus meniscus recovery
Knee Anatomy in Simple Terms
The knee connects the thigh bone (femur) to the shin bone (tibia). The kneecap (patella) glides in a groove to help your quadriceps straighten the leg. Four main ligaments keep the joint stable, including the ACL, which limits the forward slide of the shin and controls twisting. Two C-shaped pads of cartilage called the “menisci” sit between the bones. They act like shock absorbers, spread the load, and help the joint move smoothly. When you cut, pivot, or land from a jump, these parts share the work. Too much twist or force can strain a ligament or pinch and tear the meniscus
If you are having mobility concerns, issues doing the things you love, stiffness, or pain, come to ATI Physical Therapy for an initial evaluation with a licensed physical therapist. We will build a personalized plan around your needs. In most cases, no doctor’s referral is needed to get started.
ACL Tear
What it is
The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) keeps the knee stable during cutting and landing. It limits the forward slide of the shin and stops the knee from twisting too far. In sports, the ACL can tear during a quick change of direction, a sudden stop, or an awkward landing from a jump. Many people feel or hear a pop, then notice swelling.
How ACL injuries happen
ACL tears often follow these movements during sports:
- A sudden change of direction while the foot is planted.
- An awkward landing from a jump.
- Direct contact that drives the knee inward.
ACL injury symptoms
Here are common ACL injury symptoms to watch for:
- Swelling within hours of the injury.
- Feeling that the knee gives way.
- Pain with cutting, turning, or going downhill.
- Trouble trusting the knee during quick movements.
Do I need imaging
Imaging helps in certain cases, but many early decisions can be made with the use of a careful exam. Your clinician may consider an MRI to confirm a full tear and to check for other injuries.
ACL injury treatment options
Your treatment depends on your sport and stability needs. Options include:
- Acute care: to reduce swelling, restore comfortable motion, activate the quadriceps.
- Rehabilitation without surgery: Some people can return to activity with structured rehab and sometimes bracing.
- Surgical reconstruction: common for cutting and pivoting sports. Rehab before surgery improves early strength, and rehab after surgery guides return to play.
- Bracing: may be used for certain activities during phases of recovery.
How physical therapy helps
Physical therapy supports ACL injury recovery, whether you have had surgery or not, in these ways:
- Reduces swelling and restores range of motion.
- Rebuilds strength in the quadriceps, hamstrings, hips, and core.
- Trains landing mechanics, change of direction, and single-leg control.
- Uses return to sport testing to reduce re-injury risk.
ACL recovery timeline: a simple view
Typical timelines vary. In general:
- Non-surgical rehab can progress over weeks to months, depending on stability needs.
- After reconstruction, many people need several months of rehab before passing return to sport testing. Calendar dates alone are not enough to determine the full recovery timeline.
When to see a physical therapist
Right away after injury or diagnosis. Early guidance improves motion and strength, and helps you choose the best path forward.
Meniscus Tear
What it is
The meniscus is a wedge-shaped piece of cartilage that cushions your knee. Each knee has two menisci, one on the inside and one on the outside. A meniscus tear happens when the cartilage fibers split. Tears can be sudden from a twist or degenerative from wear and tear over time.
How meniscus tears happen
Meniscus tears often occur with these movements:
- Twisting the knee while the foot is planted.
- Deep squatting or getting up from a low position.
- Age-related changes that weaken the tissue.
Meniscus tear symptoms
Common meniscus tear symptoms include:
- Sharp pain with twisting or squatting.
- Swelling that may build slowly over one to two days.
- Catching, clicking, or locking.
- Pain along the joint line, either inside or outside of the knee, with bending or straightening.
Do I need imaging
Not always. A careful exam with a physical therapist often guides the next steps. An MRI can confirm the type and location of a tear if needed.
Meniscus tear treatment options
Treatment for a meniscus tear may include:
- Rehabilitation without surgery: first choice for many tears. Focus on swelling control, motion, and strength.
- Surgery, partial meniscectomy: removes the torn piece when symptoms persist or locking symptoms in the joint persist.
- Surgery, meniscus repair: stitches the tear so it can heal. Surgery is more common for tears along the outer edge, where the blood supply is better.
- Activity changes: avoid deep twisting and pivoting early on.
How physical therapy helps
Physical therapy helps by:
- Calming pain and swelling, then restoring motion.
- Building quadriceps, hamstrings, and hip strength for better support.
- Training balance and control for turning, stairs, and uneven ground.
- Guiding safe progress after meniscus surgery when needed.
Meniscus recovery timeline, a simple view
Recovery depends on the tear type and treatment:
- Many non-surgical cases improve in several weeks with the right plan.
- After a partial meniscectomy, walking and daily tasks often return within days to weeks.
- After a meniscus repair, the early phase is more protected, with a longer build back over months.
When to see a physical therapist
If knee pain limits walking, squatting, stairs, or sport, or if the knee feels like it catches or locks. Early rehab helps you move with more confidence.
ACL vs. Meniscus: How to Tell the Difference
What you might feel
Symptoms differ in these ways:
- ACL tear: a pop, fast swelling, and a sense that the knee wants to give way with pivoting.
- Meniscus tear: catching or locking, pain with twisting or deep squatting, and swelling that may build more slowly.
Where it hurts
Pain patterns often point to the source:
- ACL tear: pain is often deep, and the whole knee can feel swollen and stiff.
- Meniscus tear: pain along the joint line, either inside or outside the knee.
Movement tests your clinician may use
These clinical tests help confirm the diagnosis:
- Lachman or pivot shift tests for ACL stability.
- Joint line tenderness and McMurray test for the meniscus.
- Functional checks like single-leg balance, step downs, and hop testing as you recover.
Quick self-check
Use these simple cues to guide next steps:
- Heard a “pop” with fast swelling, and the knee feels unstable. Think ACL injury.
- Knee catches or locks and hurts along the joint line. Think meniscus tear.
- Not sure. Book an evaluation so a licensed physical therapist can examine your knee and start a plan.
Home Care Basics
Simple steps can ease knee pain in the first few days:
- Rest from painful twisting and cutting.
- Elevate and use ice for swelling in the first couple of days.
- Use a brace or crutches if your clinician advises.
- Keep the knee moving within a pain-free range to prevent stiffness.
- Stop if pain increases and contact your clinician for guidance.
How to Start Knee PT in 3 Steps
Getting started is easy:
- Book an evaluation. Share how the injury happened, your goals, and timelines.
- Get a personalized plan. Your therapist will outline exercises, activity changes, and pain relief strategies.
- Check in and progress. Follow-ups, adjust your plan, and test readiness for daily life and sport.
When to See a Physical Therapist
Consider an evaluation if any of the following apply:
- Your knee swells after activity or gives way with pivoting.
- You have sharp joint line pain, catching, or locking.
- Pain limits stairs, squats, or daily activity.
- You want a plan for safe knee injury recovery and return to sport.
A licensed physical therapist can assess motion, strength, and balance, then build a plan that fits your goals and sport. If you or a loved one has new knee pain from sports, twisting, or a misstep, come to ATI Physical Therapy for an initial evaluation with a licensed physical therapist. We will build a personalized plan around your needs. In most cases, no doctor’s referral is needed to get started.
Ready to take the next step?
Book an Evaluation Today
Frequently Asked Questions
What are common knee injury symptoms after a twist?
Swelling, stiffness, and pain with turning can follow a twist. A pop and quick swelling suggest an ACL tear. Catching or locking suggests a meniscus tear.
Can a meniscus tear heal without surgery?
Yes, many do. Rehab can reduce pain and improve function. Some tears with good blood supply can heal over time. Your clinician will advise you based on tear type and symptoms.
How long is ACL injury recovery?
Timelines vary. With surgery, many people need several months of rehab and must pass strength and hop tests before returning to sport. Without surgery, some people return to activity sooner, depending on stability needs.
Do I always need an MRI for a knee injury?
Not always. A careful exam with a physical therapist can guide early choices. An MRI is helpful when the diagnosis is unclear, symptoms persist, or surgery is being considered.
Is it safe to exercise with a knee injury?
Gentle motion and light strengthening are often helpful. Avoid twisting, deep pivots, and painful moves. Stop if your pain increases and ask your therapist what is right for your case.